Articles ·

D&D 5e Homebrew Guide: Build, Balance and Share Your Own Content

A practical D&D 5e homebrew guide: pick the rules version, design classes, monsters and items, playtest them, and share drafts with other creators.

Good homebrew starts with a one-sentence idea, a clear rules version, and a plan to test it with real players before it reaches your whole table. Everything else is craft: copying the structure of official content, changing as little as you can, and fixing what breaks in play. You can do all of that in one browser tab with Aeternum, where custom classes, creatures and equipment feed computed character sheets and live dice rolls, so a draft is playable the same evening you write it.

This guide is for game masters and players who want to make their own D&D 5e material and are not sure where to begin. It covers what homebrew is, which rules to build on, how to design the main content types, how to playtest, and how to share a draft and collect feedback.

TL;DR

Homebrew is any D&D material not published by Wizards of the Coast. Your DM decides what is allowed at the table.

Decide first whether you are building for the 2014 or the 2024 rules. Mixing them is the most common source of broken characters.

Build on proven patterns: reskin or adjust existing abilities before inventing new mechanics, and write a one-sentence pitch for every design.

Playtest in stages: on paper, in solo builds, then with other people who did not write it.

Run the draft on a sheet that does the math and rolls the dice, so testers spend their time playing instead of calculating.

Table of Contents

What homebrew means in 5e

Pick your rules version before you design anything

A repeatable way to design homebrew

Designing the main content types

Balance and playtest in three passes

Collaborating and sharing drafts

What it costs to build and test on Aeternum

Our perspective

FAQ

Sources

What homebrew means in 5e

Homebrew is fan-made D&D material: campaigns, settings, races, classes, backgrounds, feats, weapons and magic items. Explore DnD notes the term has been in use since 2003, and that homebrew has to be approved by your DM, who can change or remove it.

The definition is broad. The 5eTools community wiki counts anything not written and published by Wizards of the Coast, including well-known third-party books and community-written content. A custom monster for next Friday's session and a 200-page third-party supplement are both homebrew.

You may also see Unearthed Arcana. It is the official playtest column that has appeared roughly monthly since February 2015. One fan writer describes it as sanctioned homebrew: official in origin, but not finished canon. It is a useful model for how designers present experimental material.

Pick your rules version before you design anything

D&D 5e now exists in two versions at many tables. Wizards released the 2024 Free Rules on 3 September 2024, and the D&D Homebrew Wiki describes the 2024 rules as semi-backward compatible: 2014 rules still apply unless a 2024 rule replaces them.

That compatibility is partial, so decide up front. Anima's resource page lists the differences that matter most for homebrew:

In 2024, ability score increases come from the background, not the race.

"Race" becomes "species."

Every background grants an Origin feat.

All subclasses arrive at 3rd level.

Exhaustion costs 2 on d20 tests and 5 feet of speed per level.

The practical consequence is double-dipping. A 2014-style species that grants its own ability score increases, combined with a 2024 background, hands a character more than the designer intended. The same page recommends settling at session zero which version is the default, and keeping a dated written log of every house rule and approved homebrew option, because rulings from the first sessions resurface months later.

If you plan to publish, know the legal footing too. In April 2025 Wizards released SRD 5.2 under a Creative Commons license, which lets third-party creators reference and use the base rules without a licensing fee. It does not cover streaming, fan art, cosplay and similar fan content, which fall under separate fan content rules.

Also worth knowing for monsters: the 2024 Dungeon Master's Guide dropped the old monster-count multiplier, and designer James Wyatt told Screen Rant that the math was off for large groups. If you build encounters around custom creatures, check which encounter-building method your table uses.

A repeatable way to design homebrew

Whatever you are making, the same four moves apply.

Write the pitch in one sentence. "A frontier healer who trades hit points for terrain control." If you cannot say it in a sentence, you cannot balance it.

Check that it does not already exist. Many ideas are an existing class with a different subclass, or a reskinned species.

Find the closest official benchmark. Every new piece of content should sit next to a published equivalent at the same level or rarity.

Change less than you want to. Explore DnD suggests that the easiest path to safe homebrew is tweaking or reskinning existing abilities, because proven mechanics keep you from accidentally over- or under-powering the result.

Create a Free account · View plans · All articles

More from Aeternum